Glen’s take · Why we chose this story
A true story, researched by hand and told with AI.
Primary source goldmanprize.org
Open the original on goldmanprize.orgIn short the story, from goldmanprize.org
High in the Andes of northern Peru, at an average elevation over 4,000 metres, the lakes of the Conga area sit at the headwaters of five small watersheds (Fernández-Rubio, López García & Martins Carvalho, IMWA 2015). The Goldman Environmental Prize describes the setting as "Cajamarca's páramo ecosystem, a high-altitude biologically diverse wetland." Source · goldmanprize.org
How the headwater works: an independent international expert review commissioned by Peru's Presidency of the Council of Ministers found that groundwater there sits mainly in shallow "cutaneous (skin)" aquifers that fill "only following the seasonal precipitation," and that this water feeds the lagoons and "the surface water runoff of ravines, gorges and rivers." The same review noted "a structural deficit of water" in the dry season (IMWA 2015). Páramo soils are high in organic matter, which "contributes to water retention in the soil" (Páramo, Wikipedia), and headwater wetlands are "topographically and geologically predisposed to store water" (USF Water Institute). Source · goldmanprize.org
Laguna Azul, a freshwater lake near Máxima Acuña's land, "provides drinking and irrigation water for numerous downstream communities" (Goldman Prize blog, 2017). Her lawyer, Mirtha Vásquez, said it "feeds into five streams serving Cajamarca and several other regions, supporting thousands of people" (Goldman Prize Q&A). Source · goldmanprize.org
In 2010 the companies behind the Yanacocha mine proposed the Conga gold mine, which called for draining four lakes (Goldman Prize). Perol and Mala would be removed for open pits; Azul and Chica would be covered by a waste dump. Four reservoirs would store runoff in the wet season and release it in the dry season (IMWA 2015). The 2012 expert review judged the reservoirs could replace the lost storage, and still recommended keeping two of the four lakes and studying ways to keep the waste off Azul and Chica, given their importance (Actualidad Ambiental). Many people downstream rejected replacing natural lakes with reservoirs (Global Voices, 2011). Source · goldmanprize.org
Máxima Acuña and her husband bought land at Tragadero Grande in 1994. In 2011 the mining company demanded she leave; she refused. The Cajamarca regional courts ruled in her favour in December 2014, and on May 3, 2017, Peru's Supreme Court absolved her of all charges (Goldman Prize blog). "The land is our livelihood. It feeds us, gives us water... everything that we need" (Goldman Prize Q&A). EarthRights International describes Conga as temporarily suspended, due in part to the opposition of local communities. Source · goldmanprize.org
The read Glen’s take, in his words
High in the Andes of northern Peru, more than four thousand metres up, sits a small lake called Laguna Azul. It's part of a high, wet landscape in Cajamarca that the Goldman Prize describes as páramo, a biologically diverse wetland.
I'm Glen Kerby. This is a story about where water starts, and what happens downstream when that starting point is put at risk. My guide is a farmer who lived right beside the lake.
First, how a headwater works. In the wet season, rain falls on the high ground. Páramo soils are rich in organic matter, and that helps them hold water. An international expert review of this area, written for Peru's government, found that the groundwater up there sits in shallow layers that fill with the seasonal rain. That water feeds the lakes, and the ravines and rivers below. So the high ground works like storage. It takes in the rainy season and gives it back over time, when farms and villages downstream need it most.
The Goldman Prize says Laguna Azul provides drinking and irrigation water for numerous downstream communities. A lawyer for the families there put it simply. Laguna Azul feeds into five streams, supporting thousands of people.
In 2010, the companies behind the nearby Yanacocha mine proposed a new gold mine called Conga. The plan called for draining four lakes. Two would be removed to dig open pits. The other two, including Azul, would be covered by a waste dump. Source · goldmanprize.org
The company's answer was engineering. Four reservoirs would store runoff in the rainy season and release it in the dry season. The expert review judged that could replace the lost storage. But it also recommended keeping two of the four lakes, given their importance.
Many people below didn't accept the swap. To them, a natural lake that fills itself wasn't the same as a reservoir someone else runs.
That's where Máxima Acuña comes in. In 1994, she and her husband bought land near Laguna Azul. In 2011, the mining company demanded she leave. She refused. In 2014, the courts of Cajamarca ruled in her favour, and in May 2017, Peru's Supreme Court absolved her of all charges. Source · goldmanprize.org
She knew that water firsthand. She told the Goldman Prize, the land is our livelihood. It feeds us, gives us water, everything that we need. Asked how people use the lake water, the answer was short. To drink. For everything. Because it's natural, clean and uncontaminated.
Here's where it stands. EarthRights International describes Conga as temporarily suspended, due in part to the opposition of local communities.
So here's the water lesson. A tap downstream is only as reliable as the headwater above it. Lakes and wetlands at the top of a watershed store the wet season for the dry one, at no one's command. Protect the place where water starts, and the people below keep water to drink.
That's why Máxima Acuña has a place in the I Drink Living Water Research Library. The full story, and the expert review, are on her research page.
Questions answered from this page
What is this story about?
High in the Andes of northern Peru, at an average elevation over 4,000 metres, the lakes of the Conga area sit at the headwaters of five small watersheds (Fernández-Rubio, López García & Martins Carvalho, IMWA 2015). The Goldman Environmental Prize describes the setting as "Cajamarca's páramo ecosystem, a high-altitude biologically diverse wetland."
Why did Glen Kerby choose this story?
I chose Máxima Acuña because her story starts where water starts. Laguna Azul and the wetlands around it store the rainy season for the dry one, and families below drink from that storage. A tap downstream is only as reliable as the headwater above it.
Where can I read the original?
It was published by goldmanprize.org as “Máxima Acuña, 2016 Goldman Prize Recipient, South and Central America”, at https://www.goldmanprize.org/recipient/maxima-acuna/.
Go to the source their work, in full
“Máxima Acuña, 2016 Goldman Prize Recipient, South and Central America”
Published by goldmanprize.org. Read it where it was reported.