Glen’s take · Why we chose this story
A true story, researched by hand and told with AI.
Primary source goldmanprize.org
Open the original on goldmanprize.orgIn short the story, from goldmanprize.org
Formosa Plastics' Point Comfort plant sits on Lavaca Bay and Cox Creek on the Texas Gulf Coast. It started operating in 1983 and is Formosa's largest plastics facility in the United States (Goldman Environmental Prize). It makes nurdles, tiny plastic pellets that are the raw material for plastic products of all kinds, from water bottles to car parts. Source · goldmanprize.org
Upper Lavaca Bay flows into Matagorda Bay and on into the Gulf of Mexico (Living on Earth, May 2023). Source · goldmanprize.org
Diane Wilson is a lifelong shrimper and fourth-generation fisherwoman from Calhoun County. In 2008 a former Formosa worker contacted her about the plant's plastic pollution (Goldman). She describes plastic lost at almost every step, in packaging and in loading trains and trucks, plus plastic powder, and she tracked it from 13 stormwater outfalls and one major industrial outfall; a stormwater outfall "is not supposed to have anything but water in it" (Living on Earth; Diane Wilson, New Security Beat, Sep 2022). Because nurdles are similar in size and shape to fish eggs, marine animals often mistake them for food, and here they are also contaminated with mercury from the nearby Lavaca Bay Mercury Superfund site. The bay is home to more than 400 bird species, dolphins and sea turtles (Goldman). Source · goldmanprize.org
Wilson identified discharge points, organized volunteer teams for near-daily sampling by foot and kayak, and collected more than 40 million nurdles in four years, documented in more than 7,000 photos and videos. When the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality stopped responding, she pursued a citizen lawsuit (Goldman). In July 2017 she and San Antonio Bay Estuarine Waterkeeper sued Formosa under the Clean Water Act; the plant's permit covered the discharge of floating solids, and plastic floats (The Texas Tribune, Jun 2019; New Security Beat). On the first day of trial she personally presented 2,400 samples (Goldman), and discovery documents showed a single release of about 170,000 pounds of pellets from outfall pipe six (New Security Beat; Living on Earth gives 167,000). Source · goldmanprize.org
On June 27, 2019, U.S. District Judge Kenneth M. Hoyt found Formosa had violated its permit on floating solids since January 31, 2016, called the violations enormous, and called the company "a serial offender." "The judge saw us and he heard us," Wilson said (The Texas Tribune, Jun 28 2019). On December 3, 2019 the judge approved a settlement: zero discharge of all plastics, cleanup of existing pollution, improved wastewater and stormwater discharge facilities, holding ponds to contain all stormwater on the property, and more stormwater drainage capacity (The Texas Tribune, Dec 3 2019). Source · goldmanprize.org
Citizens kept the right to monitor. Wilson writes that their engineering expert built a wastewater sampling device that detected 299 violations in the first year after the ruling (New Security Beat). She still leads weekly nurdle patrols, and in 2021 the state strengthened discharge requirements for companies that make and handle nurdles (Goldman). "The water to me is real, it's alive, it has value, it's family" (Living on Earth). Source · goldmanprize.org
The read Glen’s take, in his words
Lavaca Bay sits on the Texas Gulf Coast. On its shore, at Point Comfort, Formosa Plastics runs its largest plastics plant in the United States.
The plant makes tiny plastic pellets called nurdles, the raw material for plastic products of all kinds, from water bottles to car parts.
I'm Glen Kerby. Today we follow those pellets from the plant into the bay, with Diane Wilson as our guide.
Wilson is a lifelong shrimper and a fourth generation fisherwoman from Calhoun County. In 2008, a former Formosa worker came to her about the plant's plastic pollution. Source · goldmanprize.org
So how does a pellet get from a factory into a bay? Wilson says the plant loses plastic at almost every step, in packaging and in loading trains and trucks. And the plastic shows up in the plant's outfalls. Wilson tracked thirteen stormwater outfalls and one major industrial outfall. A stormwater outfall, she points out, is not supposed to carry anything but water.
The Goldman Prize says nurdles look like fish eggs, so marine animals mistake them for food. And here they pick up mercury from the Lavaca Bay Mercury Superfund site nearby.
Here is how she built the evidence. She found the discharge points, by kayak and on foot. She organized volunteer teams to sample almost every day. In four years, they collected more than forty million nurdles. When the state agency stopped responding, she turned to a citizen lawsuit.
In July 2017, Wilson and San Antonio Bay Estuarine Waterkeeper sued Formosa under the Clean Water Act. The plant's permit covered the discharge of floating solids, and plastic pellets float. At trial in 2019, she personally presented two thousand four hundred samples on the first day. Source · goldmanprize.org
In June 2019, federal Judge Kenneth Hoyt ruled that Formosa had violated its permit since January 2016, and called the company a serial offender. "The judge saw us and he heard us," Wilson said. Source · goldmanprize.org
That December, the judge approved a settlement. Formosa agreed to zero discharge of all plastics and to clean up existing pollution.
So what does zero discharge look like on the ground? The Texas Tribune reports Formosa agreed to improve its wastewater and stormwater facilities, including holding ponds to contain all the stormwater on the property.
And the community keeps checking. Wilson says their engineering expert built a wastewater sampling device that found two hundred ninety nine violations in the first year after the ruling. The Goldman Prize says she still leads nurdle patrols every week. In 2021, the state strengthened discharge rules for companies that handle nurdles. Source · goldmanprize.org
She describes the bay this way. "The water to me is real, it's alive, it has value, it's family."
What I take from this is that clean water depends on someone counting. Daily sampling turned a shoreline into evidence, and the evidence turned into holding ponds and rules that keep plastic out of a bay where families fish.
This is why we're making space for Diane Wilson in the I Drink Living Water Research Library.
Read the full story, and its sources, on the I Drink Living Water research page for Diane Wilson.
Questions answered from this page
What is this story about?
Formosa Plastics' Point Comfort plant sits on Lavaca Bay and Cox Creek on the Texas Gulf Coast. It started operating in 1983 and is Formosa's largest plastics facility in the United States (Goldman Environmental Prize). It makes nurdles, tiny plastic pellets that are the raw material for plastic products of all kinds, from water bottles to car parts.
Why did Glen Kerby choose this story?
I chose Diane Wilson because she shows that clean water depends on someone counting. She and her volunteers walked and paddled the shoreline almost every day, and that daily sampling turned a bay into evidence a federal court could not ignore. The evidence turned into holding ponds and rules that keep plastic out of a bay where families fish.
Where can I read the original?
It was published by goldmanprize.org as “Diane Wilson, 2023 Goldman Environmental Prize, North America”, at https://www.goldmanprize.org/recipient/diane-wilson/.
Go to the source their work, in full
“Diane Wilson, 2023 Goldman Environmental Prize, North America”
Published by goldmanprize.org. Read it where it was reported.